Taking the Guesswork out of Lifting

Many comedians have pretended to lift a box that looks heavy to get a laugh. The box turns out to be light, and the jokester falls over. This may be funny on the stage, but it’s a serious problem for workers. People who lift and handle items for a living are called manual material handlers (MMHs). Back injury is their number one enemy.

Lifting a load of unexpected or unknown weight is dangerous. The lifter may think it weighs more than it does. Getting the body ready to lift an object depends on knowing how much the item weighs. Using more force than is needed to move materials can increase the risk of falling backwards. The same risk applies to unstable loads or loads that shift suddenly, such as liquids.

MMHs must prepare their bodies each time they lift an object. The muscles and body posture are part of this preparation phase of lifting. Keeping the center of gravity steady is an important part of keeping balance without falling over.

Bending the trunk closer to the object lowers the center of gravity. This is called the stoop method of lifting. Stooping or bending over to lift puts greater strain on the low back. It’s easier to keep balance with the stoop method compared to the squat method of lifting.

Scientists are studying ways to prevent injuries for MMHs. More research is needed to mimic actual work settings. This will provide helpful information for different jobs where varying loads are lifted.

Seeing the Spine in 3D

In an effort to help patients with low back pain, scientists are studying how the spine moves. We know that patients with chronic low back pain have reduced motion in the spine. New three-dimensional (3D) equipment is allowing researchers to study patterns of motion.

Now that we know “how much” the spine moves, the next step is to find out “how” it moves. The “how” of spine movement is referred to as patterns of motion. Three directions of motion were studied: bending forward and back, bending to the side, and turning or rotating to one side.

In the normal, healthy spine, the spine moves through each of these motions. Some movement patterns occur at the same time. For example, bending to the side also causes the joint to turn, or rotate. This pattern of two motions together is the same for everyone who doesn’t have back pain.

In patients with chronic low back pain, it seems that there are up to three different ways to do each motion. There may be side bending and rotation to the same side or side bending with no rotation at all. Only a small number of patients with back pain have the normal side bending with rotation to the opposite side. 

This new information will help doctors connect the patient’s symptoms with back function. It may be possible for doctors to listen to patients’ symptoms and know what changes in motion are occurring inside the spine. Surgery to fuse the spine may be needed, but the hope is to find a treatment that will restore normal motion.

Sending a Message about Massage

How about a nice backrub for that chronic, aching low back pain? A massage sounds like a good idea. But at $25 to $50 per visit, it would be nice to know that it does more than just feel good. This is especially true when at least 50 other types of pain-relieving treatment are available.

Too often, promise are made that massage will relieve pain, reduce suffering, and cure the problem. Many studies over the years have looked at the results of treatment for back pain. Sometimes massage alone is studied, while other studies compare massage to one or more other options. Results can be anything from pain relief to improved function, more range of motion, or increased strength.

Using just pain relief as a measure of effectiveness, massage does work in cases of chronic back pain. It’s even better when combined with exercises and education. But don’t sign up for a massage just yet. Several studies show that manipulation or electrical stimulation is equal to, if not better than, massage.

Again the goal is short-term pain relief. The effects of these treatments on long-term pain (more than one year) are unknown. Future studies will look at the effect of various treatments on long-term results. In the meantime, massage therapy helps improve symptoms and function. It may save money by reducing doctor visits, use of drugs, and costs of other back care services. If you want to get the most from a massage, exercise regularly and educate yourself about back care in general.

Rest or Activity: Which Is Better for Low Back Pain?

Which strategy is better in the first few days after back pain: keep moving or go to bed? Two main goals doctors have when treating low back pain include pain relief and prevention of long-term problems. But how do doctors know which treatment works best?

Researchers collected data from studies of patients with low back pain. This information was analyzed and for doctors. The final results of all these studies have helped several countries write guidelines for the treatment of low back pain. Deciding whether rest or activity worked best was one of the questions answered.

For patients with low back pain that just started, four days of complete bed rest is no better than normal activity. In a way, the bed rest was worse because it required the worker to use sick leave. Since the outcome was the same with rest or activity, the sick leave was probably used unnecessarily. These results are based on patients who are employees and therefore should not be applied to the general population.

Backing Up Physical Therapy Treatments for Pregnant Women

More than half of all pregnant women report having low back pain. For most women, this goes away after pregnancy. But for about 10 percent, back pain becomes a chronic problem. How can a woman tell if she is at risk for back pain during pregnancy? Several predictors have been identified.

The most common risk factor is low back pain before pregnancy or during an earlier pregnancy. A job with physical labor is another common predictor. Other risk factors include age (younger women), smoking, and lower income level.

The exact cause of back pain among pregnant women is unknown. There are several changes during pregnancy that add to the risk of this problem. These include changes in hormones, rapid weight gain, and abdominal muscle weakness. Treatment with a physical therapist is often advised.
 
Physical therapy treatment for pregnant women with back pain should be different from patients who aren’t pregnant. This is because of the physical, biological, and mechanical changes that occur during pregnancy. A physical therapist can check each spinal level for changes in motion. This could be increased motion or a loss of motion. Muscle strength and flexibility will also be tested.

A treatment program to restore movement, improve posture, and stretch muscles can be provided. Each of these must be modified for the changes in a woman’s body during pregnancy. Physical therapists are actively studying how to do this safely and effectively. For example, stomach muscles get stretched out during pregnancy. Along with expected weight gain, this can weaken the abdominal muscles. Regular sit-ups can actually cause separation of the abdominal muscles and are therefore not advised. Therapists teach how to brace the abdominal muscles during exercise to avoid this problem.

Only a few studies are available to show which physical therapy methods are best for pregnant patients with low back pain. More studies are needed to show what works best for this group of patients.

Examining Low Back Pain after Pregnancy

Pain in the lower back or hips is one of the most common complaints of pregnancy. Unfortunately, for many women the pain doesn’t go away after giving birth.

These researchers compared the way two groups of women lifted a box. All the women recently had babies. One group had back pain that began during pregnancy, and the other group had no back pain. Joint movements were tracked as all the women stood up, bent over, and picked up a box that weighed about 20 pounds. The researchers noted that the women with back pain made some movements more slowly. They also used different joints at different times to help them lift.

The results suggest two possible reasons for back pain after pregnancy. One possibility is from a strain in the muscles and tissues of the lower back that help with bending. The other possible reason is weakness in the supportive muscles that hold the lower spine stable. Identifying the cause could help refine exercises and therapy that work for pregnant women with back pain. Then these new mothers might actually be able to pick up their growing babies without feeling pain.

Back Surgery Isn’t Only about Pain

Spinal stenosis is a common problem in older adults, causing low back and leg pain. Spinal stenosis is a narrowing of the opening where the spinal nerve roots pass from the spinal column. It is usually caused by changes in the spine that occur with aging. These changes include bone spurs, thinning of the discs, thickening of the ligaments, and overgrowth of the joint cartilage.

Pressure on the nerves from these changes causes painful symptoms, numbness and tingling, and pain with walking. Surgery to take pressure off the spinal nerve is sometimes the only treatment to successfully reduce pain. This procedure is called a nerve root decompression. The result of this treatment is varied and not always successful in reducing pain.

However, pain isn’t the only measure of success. Improved physical and social function is also important to most patients. Doctors in a London hospital interviewed patients at six weeks, six months, and one year after surgery for spinal stenosis. Most improvements occur by the six-week and six-month mark for pain and physical function, but social function continued to get better for up to a year.

Surgery for spinal stenosis may not be successful in getting rid of all your pain. If you are facing surgery to reduce symptoms from spinal stenosis, you may want to think about other factors. For example, surgery may enable you to sleep better, walk longer, and get out more. These changes may not be immediate, but you may continue to improve for up to one year after surgery.

Corking the Dike of Chronic Nerve Pain

Back pain with leg pain is often caused by a disc pressing against a nerve root in the low back. This occurs where the nerve leaves the spinal column. The condition is called lumbar radiculopathy. It is the number one cause of low back pain in adults. Some people have chronic pain over many years from this condition. Finding a treatment that works for this problem is the goal of many scientists.

The first step in treating this kind of back pain is to understand the cause of the pain. Whenever a body part is injured or damaged, the immune system works to repair it. One single event can trigger a series of responses in the body. This is like a single drop of water joining many other drops to form a waterfall. The effect is called a cascade.

The immune system has a cascade response to nerve root injury. The chemicals released to help heal the body are called neurotransmitters. These have an indirect effect on the nerve tissue.

Scientists now understand that there is a “bigger picture” to this healing response. Once the injury sets up the cascade, the overall nervous system takes part, too. White blood cells and many different neurotransmitters are quick to arrive at the site of damage.

Somehow, these chemicals are able to enter the spinal cord and affect the entire nervous system. This kind of broader cascade is referred to as a “central process.” The final result is pain that doesn’t go away.

How can this waterfall of events be stopped? The next step in discovery is to find out how the uptake of chemicals occurs. This in turn will direct scientists how to interrupt the cascade and keep chronic back and leg pain from happening.

Retiring from Back Pain

Neck and back pain are major concerns for workers around the world. Work slowdown and absent workers cost companies and countries millions of dollars every year. People with chronic back pain may end up retiring on disability. Is it possible to predict who will have to retire because of disabling back pain?

A study of almost 35,000 working men and women gives some news about this. Risk factors such as smoking, obesity, general health, burn out, and job tasks were compared. Some risk factors are better than others to predict who will have a future disability.

Physically hard work is the biggest risk for disability from back pain. The second greatest risk is “burn out,” an overall feeling of being tired and worn out. The risk goes up when smoking, excess weight, and inactivity are added to the first two factors. The risk goes up again if the person has other diseases or general poor health.

When it comes to risk factors for retirement because of back pain disability, a physically demanding job is number one. Poor health and burn out add to this risk. Treatment for back pain alone isn’t enough to prevent disability retirement. Paying attention to the health, social, and emotional needs of workers is also important.

Asking the Right Questions about Back Pain

When it comes to back pain, doctors need a place to start. Knowing how severe the pain is gives doctors useful information for treatment. A survey called the Dallas Pain Questionnaire  (DPQ) may be just the right tool to help doctors. It is a short series of questions that looks at back pain in adults who are still working. It shows how pain affects function and emotions.

Many studies now show the need to consider various components of chronic back pain, including pain intensity, feelings, and level of function. The DPQ looks at four areas of life, including daily activities, work, anxiety or depression, and social interest. The answers to these questions help doctors classify patients.

The DPQ divides patients into several groups. On one end is the group with minor difficulty. At the other end are those patients with significant chronic low back pain. It further points out patients with emotional distress.

A simple and practical tool like the DPQ is just what doctors need. It helps them find out what stage of chronic back pain a patient is in. The grouping of patients points out the workers who are seriously disabled by their pain. It guides the doctor in deciding who can return to work and who can’t.

Relief from Back Pain Doesn’t Always Improve Quality of Life

There’s a weak but important link between pain, disability, and quality of life (QOL) in patients with low back pain. These are the findings of a study conducted in Spain at seven primary care centers of the Spanish National Health System. There were 195 patients in the study.

Even when treatment improved the patients’ pain, they didn’t necessarily get better. Disability and QOL remained unchanged after measurable changes in pain. Why is that? Studies show pain is influenced by physical factors such as how the muscles, joints, and ligaments work. Disability is linked more closely to psychological and social factors.

This study confirms these same findings from other reports. The authors suggest using separate measures for pain and disability. They point out that QOL depends more on how long the pain lasts than how intense it is. It’s likely that other factors besides pain also affect QOL, but more study is needed to identify them.

In this study, the researchers found QOL worsened the longer the pain lasted. In fact the measure of QOL doubled from day one to day 14. In this study, the QOL test measured several areas of health: mobility, self-care, main activity, family or leisure activities, pain, and mood.

The authors conclude that treatment must focus on improving pain, disability, and QOL. It’s likely that separate treatment programs are needed for each factor. Improving just one factor doesn’t always change the others.

Teaming Up to Treat Back Pain

For years studies have shown few therapies that work in the treatment of chronic low back pain. Doctors have tried “usual care,” which means rest, then activity, along with pain relievers.

But science may be making some progress in this area. Intense treatment with many types of care may be working. The concept is called a multidisciplinary rehabilitation program (MRP). MRP treatment involves physical therapy, psychological treatment, education, and relaxation.

Researchers in Germany put MRP to the test. They compared two groups of patients with chronic low back pain. Group one received usual care, while group two had MRP four hours every day, three days each week, for three weeks.

The results are very promising. The MRP group improved in physical and mental health with fewer days missed at work. In the authors’ opinion the MRP program was very successful.

The authors hope the program could be offered as group therapy rather than individual therapy. If MRP can be started earlier in the episode of back pain, chronic pain might be reduced. The program could be copied and offered everywhere as part of community medicine.

The doctors behind this study see MRP as a means of improving health quality of life for patients with chronic low back pain. They recommend more studies to confirm these early results before planning community-based MRP programs.

Paying a “Complement” to Other Health Providers

Where do people get help when they have back pain? In any given year, one-third of all adults have at least one episode of back pain. Back pain is the second leading cause of visits to the doctor in the United States. Notably, only about 12 percent of adults with back pain see their medical doctor.

How are other people handling their back pain? Chiropractic care, massage therapy, and relaxation techniques are the three top choices. In fact, one-third of all adult back and neck pain patients get help outside the medical world.

Other health care services such as chiropractic, yoga, massage, homeopathy, and acupuncture are called complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies. Chiropractic care is the most commonly used CAM. Twenty-five percent of back and neck pain patients combine medical care along with CAM therapies.

Patients most likely to use CAM are women with pain in more than one area of the neck and back. Level of education, income, and general health don’t seem to influence who seeks help from CAM. Most patients rate CAM as “very helpful.” The effectiveness of these therapies remains unknown.

It appears from this study that only a small number of patients seek care just from a medical doctor. Also, people tend to combine CAM with care from their medical doctor. Future studies are being planned to look at the cost, harms, and benefits of CAM therapies.

Spine Fusion Update: Are Women More Magnetic Than Men?

When a back injury requires surgery, fusion is often the method of repair. Small pieces of bone are placed alongside the damaged area. This builds a bridge of bone to support the spine. Sometimes metal screws or plates are used to immobilize the area and speed healing. A quick and complete healing of the bone is important for full recovery after fusion.

Bone can be stimulated to grow with the right kind of treatment. Doctors are studying electrical and electromagnetic fields to aid the healing process. The U. S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the use of this treatment method in 1979. Since that time, this has moved from being implanted surgically to a strap-on unit in current use.

The first-ever study of this device in humans has been reported. Over 200 patients in 10 centers were included. Only those patients with bone grafts (but no metal implants) took part in the study. Everyone wore the device over the fusion, but not everyone received the stimulation. For purposes of the study, the patients and doctors didn’t know who had an active unit. For those with the active unit, the combined magnetic fields were applied every day for 30 minutes.

Treatment of spinal fusion with combined magnetic fields seems to be most effective in women. Fusion occurred in 67 percent of women with active devices. This was compared with only 35 percent of those women with a device that wasn’t active. There was no significant difference among men with or without the active device. Researchers don’t know how to explain this. Perhaps there is a difference in body functions between men and women. Or maybe women truly are more magnetic.

Defining Best Treatments for Sciatica

The usual treatment for back pain with signs of paralysis from a disc problem is surgery. Numbness, muscle weakness, and loss of movement have generally been red flags in this condition. Surgery is often recommended in these cases. A new study has been published to challenge this widely accepted practice.

Seventeen different groups of doctors participated in this study. Patients with leg pain or sciatica from the disc pressing on a spinal nerve root were observed. Half were treated with surgery to remove pressure from the nerve root. The other half received nonsurgical treatment.

Both groups were measured at one, three, and six months for pain level, muscle strength, return to work status, and use of pain medication. Recovery rates were equal for both groups (around 70 per cent). If both treatments work equally well, what are the important factors to predict recovery?

The only difference between those who got better and those who didn’t for both treatments is age. Younger patients are more likely to recovery fully no matter which treatment is used. Return to work was based on whether or not the patient had improved enough or recovered fully.

Surgical treatment of sciatica with signs of paralysis isn’t always more effective than medical management without surgery. This is a new finding about a standard treatment used for years. More studies are needed to confirm this finding. Complete paralysis still usually requires immediate surgery.

Backing Up Back Treatments That Work

There are many ways to treat low back pain, but which method is the best? How do treatments stack up against each other? A group of chiropractors and physical therapists compared four of their treatment methods.

These four types of treatment included education (called back school), joint manipulation, myofascial therapy, and manipulation combined with myofascial therapy. Joint manipulation is performed by both physical therapists and chiropractors. Myofascial therapy is a way to move and stretch the soft tissues.

Surprisingly, there were no differences in results of the four treatment methods. Two hundred patients were treated with one of the four methods. All groups showed big changes in pain and activity after three weeks. These changes were kept for six months. There wasn’t any further improvement by the end of six months.

Back school therapy and hands-on treatment by chiropractors or physical therapists had the same results. They all seem to be equally effective in treating recent low back pain. The question still remains as to whether people who receive no treatment would do as well as the groups who got these treatments.

Keeping Lumbar Fusion “Simple”

Sometimes back pain just won’t go away, even with medications, rest, or exercise. For chronic low back pain, surgery may be the next step. When it comes to back surgery, doctors have several options. The choice may be decided by the where the pain is coming from.

Sometimes back pain comes from the joints of the spine or the disc between the spinal bones. For some patients, pain comes from both of these areas. Preventing motion in the spine by fusing two bones together often helps reduce painful symptoms.

There are at least three ways to fuse spine bones together. The simplest way is to lay bone graft along the back edge of the spine. This technique is called posterolateral fusion. Another way is us use screws or metal plates to hold the bones together and improve healing of the bone graft. Bone graft can also be placed in front, back, or all the way around two or more spine bones. It would be very helpful if the surgeon knew which one had the best results, with the fewest problems.

Doctors in Sweden have joined together to look at cases of spinal fusion. The three methods of fusing the spine were studied and compared based on pain, disability status, and number of patients who returned to work. It turns out that all three methods reduce pain and disability equally. This means that the surgeon may be able to use the simplest of the three methods, posterolateral fusion. This approach has the shortest operation time. No blood transfusion is needed, and the patient stays fewer days in the hospital.

Fusion Fact Finding

Low back pain that doesn’t go away after six months is called chronic. Chronic low back pain is now one of the most common reasons for early retirement in the United States and other western countries.

Doctors are under increased pressure to successfully treat back pain, as more and more adults suffer from this problem. As a result, the number of spinal fusions done in the last 15 years has increased. Many physicians debate just who should have a spinal fusion and what kind of fusion should be done.

Using bone graft to fuse two or more bones together in the low back area is one option. Placing the graft along the back sides of the spinal column is a procedure called posterolateral fusion. Another method of fusion is to add a screw as an extra support for the spine and to increase the success of the fusion. Until recently, no one knew which method was better.

Doctors in Denmark carried out a study to see whether posterolateral fusion worked better by adding screws. They studied 129 people over a period of five years. For the most part, there were no major differences in the final results with the two methods. The only exception was for back patients needing fusion due to degenerative loosening within two or more spine bones. These patients fared better with addition of screws.

Adding a screw during lumbar fusion increases the operating time and amount of blood loss. In most cases there is no advantage to having a spinal fusion with addition of the screw. Depending on the cause of their chronic low back pain, patients needing fusion surgery may benefit by having posterolateral fusion alone, without the addition of screws. Doctors use studies like this one to choose the best treatments for each patient.

Children Brace Themselves for Sports

School-aged athletes can develop low back pain (LBP). The most common cause of LBP in this age group is a condition called spondylolysis. This is a small fracture in the part of the vertebra (back bone) that forms the spinal canal.

It was once thought that spondylolysis was always a defect present at birth. Now, it’s known that most of cases of spondylolysis are caused by repeated trauma. Sports like gymnastics, figure skating, and dance are the biggest problems. In these sports, the children are extending the spine over and over. In football, trauma from impact is a risk factor.

Doctors at Children’s Hospital in Boston report success with a specific treatment for spondylolysis. They are using the modified Boston Overlap Brace combined with physical therapy. The brace is a hard plastic shell that wraps around the low back and waist and is secured with Velcro straps.

Children with mild to moderate symptoms are generally able to return to full sports activity after six weeks. Most children are very faithful about wearing the brace and following physical therapists’ instructions. They want to return to sports as soon as possible. The brace is generally worn up to 23 hours a day for six months and then gradually weaned away.

Exercise Works for Chronic Back Pain

Physical therapy is a common part of the treatment for chronic low back pain. Chronic back pain is defined as pain that lasts beyond the expected time for healing. This is usually after three months.

There are many different ways to treat back pain. Exercise is one of them. There are also many different kinds of exercise programs. Therapists would like to know which kind works the best. In an effort to answer this question, therapists in Denmark and Sweden joined together. They studied two separate kinds of exercise programs used for chronic low back patients.

The first group used a method called McKenzie exercises. This therapy uses repeated movements and positions held for a length of time. The aim of this treatment is to give rapid relief from pain and return normal motion. The second method, strength training, has several parts. These include a warm up period on a bike, repeated exercises for the low back and pelvic muscles, intense back flexion and extension exercises, and stretching.

The results of each treatment were measured at two months and eight months. The McKenzie group had more function and less disability at the two-month marker. There were no differences in pain at any time between the two groups. At the end of the eight months, there were no differences at all in the final result between the two groups.

All back studies agree that exercise therapy is a good way to treat low back pain. The exact kind of exercise that is best remains unknown. The first study comparing strengthening exercises versus McKenzie exercises has been done. Active exercises are equally effective in patients with chronic low back pain.

More study is needed in this area to match specific back problems with each type of exercise. This will help therapists prescribe the right exercise for each problem.