I’m seeing a physical therapist for low back pain that started two weeks ago. The treatment doesn’t seem to be focused on getting rid of the pain. Shouldn’t that be first?

Many studies show that acute back pain will go away in time without specific treatment. Staying active during the healing phase is most important. If the therapist can help you gain a sense of control over your pain then you’ll be more likely to keep active.

Most PT programs for back pain are designed for each individual. The choice of treatment is usually up to the therapist. It’s always a good idea to ask your PT to explain the program you’re following. If you understand why you’re doing what you’re doing, you’ll likely stick with it longer.

Four out of my five closest friends have had a spinal fusion. We’re all in our 70s with back pain. Should I have this done too?

It’s true the longer we live the more likely we’ll suffer from a degenerative condition in the spine. Spinal fusion has become a very popular way to treat the problem. Medicare reports a 57 percent increase in the number of enrollees who have had this operation in the last 10 years.

Spinal fusion accounts for 30 percent of all operations done on the spine. This is up from 23 percent 10 years ago.

Not everyone with back pain can benefit from a spinal fusion. And studies show about a 50 percent failure rate. The most common problem is increased motion at the next spinal segment. Ongoing research is underway to find a way to prevent this from happening.

There may be other ways to treat your back condition before surgery. See your doctor soon for an evaluation and find out what are your options.

I’ve been thinking about having my low back fused based on my doctor’s advice. When I went on-line to read more about it, I saw there can be lots of problems later. This is especially true when the level below the fusion starts to break down. Since I’m having the last two vertebrae fused, am I safe from this problem?

Spinal fusion has become a very popular way to treat spinal instability. Bone graft material and/or rods and screws are used to hold two vertebral bones together. The fusion keeps them from moving and stops the pain and disability.

The problem with this treatment is that the segments above and below the fusion are subjected to increased loads and stresses. Then they start to degenerate and become unstable.

Even if you have the L45 level fused, there is still motion where the last vertebra (L5) meets the sacrum (S1) and at the level above (L34). A study was done at the Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, Oregon to compare an L45 fusion with an L4S1 fusion.

They found overall spinal stiffness increased more for the L4S1 fusion compared to the L45 fusion. It could be that extending the fusion down to S1 is the answer. This was the first study done using cadaver spines. More studies will be needed before fusion extension is done routinely. Still, it’s worth asking your doctor this question. Perhaps it will be a good option for you.

My mother had spinal surgery about six months ago for chronic low back pain. The pain has come back in a slightly different spot. The doctor says she has “adjacent segment degeneration.” What is this and what happens next?

Adjacent means “next to” and degeneration refers to a breaking down process. It sounds like your mother had a spinal fusion (two bones held together to prevent motion).

Adjacent segment degeneration (ASD) is a common problem after spinal fusion. The vertebrae on either side of the fusion can become unstable. Increased motion at these levels causes even more break down of the nearby segments. Adjacent segment degeneration
is the number one cause of spinal fusion failure.

This problem presents itself in many different ways. The vertebrae might slip forward closing off the space for the spinal nerves. This is called stenosis. The discs in
between the vertebral bones can start to break down. The facet joints in the spine are damaged. The vertebral bones can even break.

Up to 50 percent of all patients with lumbar fusion show X-ray changes linked to ASD. Not everyone with X-ray signs of ASD have problems. They may still be able to function fully. But many patients end up having a second operation when pain and disability occur.

I’m a nurse with 25 years of experience, so you know I’m not a spring chicken. I heard a news report about a study in Sweden comparing trained judo fighters that’s supposed to help nurses. The fighters lifted patients while the abdominal pressure and muscle activity was measured. How’s a study like this going to help someone like me?

You’re right of course. The authors of this study even mention the limitations of their own study. They pointed out the subjects in the study were well-trained and used to heavy loads on the trunk. They aren’t trying to use the results of their study to make conclusions about the general adult population.

A study of this type can still help nurses. Judo fighters rarely have back problems. If researchers can map out how they move and use their muscles, then maybe it will be possible to help train anyone lifting heavy loads how to lift and avoid injuries.

The study only included 10 subjects, so the size of the sample was small, too. More studies are needed, but scientists have to start somewhere!

I’m a nursing supervisor in a large acute care hospital. Many nurses have low back pain from lifting patients. Should we try to recruit more male nurses to combat this problem? Do male nurses have fewer injuries lifting patients compared to women?

It’s true that nurses are at increased risk for back injury from patient handling. Sudden, unexpected body movements can occur when a patient loses his or her balance or faints.

We haven’t found any studies comparing male to female nurses and lifting. There is a recent study from Denmark that might offer some helpful information. Researchers used 10 well-trained judo fighters to “catch” falling patients. The patient was a 33-year old healthy male who weighed 220 pounds.

Pressure inside the abdomen and force of abdominal muscle contraction were measured for each catch made. These two factors are known to increase spinal stability. They do this by increasing the “stiffness” of the spine when it’s suddenly exposed to a heavy or
shifting load.

In this study no one used the full intra-abdominal pressure (IAP) possible, but women used a higher IAP for the same load as men. Other studies show women have equal or greater endurance in the back muscles compared to men when lifting the same amount of weight or load. Men are usually stronger than women and can lift heavier loads.

My husband had back surgery yesterday. I read the instruction sheet that said to “avoid using Valsalva’s maneuver.” What is this?

Valsalva’s maneuver occurs when you hold your breath and lift something or bear down like when straining to have a bowel movement. It’s an increase in the pressure inside the chest and abdomen. It also occurs when lifting heavy objects or anytime you cough or sneeze forcibly.

The maneuver causes trapping of blood in the large veins, keeping it from moving into the chest and heart. When the breath is let out, the pressure drops and the blood moves quickly through the heart. This increases the heart rate and blood pressure.

Most patients are advised to avoid this maneuver after any major surgery. It can bring about a heart attack in anyone with heart disease. It can rupture a weak blood vessel. It can also disrupt the spine in patients who have just had back surgery.

Your husband should follow any instructions given about lifting. Whenever lifting he should contract his abdominal muscles by pulling his belly button in toward his spine. He should not hold his breath. A good way to lift is to take a normal breath, pull the abdominals in, and let the breath out while lifting while keeping the abdominal muscles tight until the lift is done.

What is a lumbar facet syndrome? My doctor says this is what I’ve got. All I know is there’s a lot of low back pain on one side. I can hardly sit or twist to one side.

Lumbar facet syndrome is a term used to describe a pattern of pain. The patient usually has:

  • pain with back extension
  • decreased low back range of motion, especially in extension and rotation (turning to one side)
  • pain or tenderness over the facet joint of the spine
  • pain that is described as “deep aching”
  • pain in the low back on one side, both sides, or back and buttock pain
  • pain going down as far as the knee but not causing foot pain

    Some of these symptoms also occur with a disc problem. If the doctor has ruled out a disc problem, the term lumbar facet syndrome (LFS) is often used. It describes a biomechanical problem of the joint but could also include changes in the ligaments and muscles.

    There isn’t a specific test to prove someone has LFS and the exact cause of the pain remains unknown.

  • I hurt my back playing tennis last week. I always hear about tennis elbow (which I’ve never had), but never about back injuries. Are back injuries unusual in tennis players?

    Not at all. The demands put on the body during tennis can cause a wide range of injuries including low back, arm, and leg problems. Surprisingly, more nontennis players suffer from “tennis elbow” than actual tennis players. Tennis elbow can occur in anyone using the hand and forearm in a repetitive action.

    Back injuries are far more common affecting up to half of all elite tennis players. Elite means the player is either a ranked player or plays in tournaments at the college or
    professional level. The number of back injuries may be different for players in adult tennis leagues. No studies have been reported on this group.

    Researchers are starting to look for reasons for these injuries. They hope to find ways to prevent back problems. Studies measuring the strength of trunk muscles in 27,000 normal, uninjured subjects (ages 10 to 79) report equal strength from side to side. Future studies will take the same measurements in injured tennis players and compare them. This may give us some ideas for preventing back injuries in this sport.

    My doctor says I’m not a good candidate for the new artificial disc replacements. What would happen if I went ahead and got one anyway?

    It might be helpful to know why your orthopedic surgeon doesn’t think the artificial disc replacement (ADR) would work for you. There have been enough studies done now to show some patients have risk factors that put them at risk for a poor result. You may be one of these patients.

    For example congenital defects of the vertebral bones may make an ADR impossible to get in place. Researchers report the presurgical evaluation is the most critical factor for a successful result.

    The condition of your bones as well as your overall health are also important factors. Severe osteoporosis may result in fracture as a complication. This could compromise the success of an ADR.

    These are just a few examples of the possibilities. You really should find out more from your surgeon before making a final decision.

    I have three discs that are getting thin from the aging process. One disc (the worst one) is going to be replaced with an artificial implant. Will this affect the height of the other two discs?

    Probably not. Using X-rays, MRIs, and a special imaging study called fluoroscopy researchers have shown there are no changes in the height of discs directly above or below the implant.

    Loosening of the implant, dislocations, or sinking into the bone can actually decrease the height of the replaced disc. Let’s hope you don’t run into any of those problems.

    I’m a school nurse in an elementary and middle school. I see students of all ages starting to have back pain. It seems like much more than it used to be. Is there any known cause of this problem in such young children?

    Adults have a high lifetime risk (80 percent) of having at least one episode of back pain. This figure is reportedly less in children and adolescents.

    Increasing episodes of back pain in groups ages 14 to 18 years old have been reported around the world. Very little is known about back pain between ages 14 to 18 and young adulthood.

    It appears that the rates of back pain are doubling in this age group. Doctors are concerned because a previous history of back pain is a risk factor for future episodes of back pain.

    Studies seem to show that the major factors are psychosocial not physical. Emotional and conduct problems are strongly linked with low back pain in this age group.

    I just graduated from nursing school. The first three hospitals I applied at all required preemployment screening. They weren’t screening for drugs like I expected. They were screening for back pain. What’s going on?

    Nurses seem to have a high prevalence of back pain and disability. Understandably, employers want to avoid having to pay mega-dollars for back care for so many of their workers.

    Studies clearly show that a previous history of back pain is a risk factor for future episodes of back problems. A recent study of nursing students and nurses from Finland shows a direct link between nursing students with back pain (before they ever treated patients) and future disability from back pain.

    Pre-employment screening is to protect the hiring agency before a problem develops. Pre-nursing school screening may be next.

    I’m thinking about going to nursing school. I heard that many nurses have to quit nursing because of back pain. Is this true?

    Studies of back pain and occupational health have been done. One from the Institute of Occupational Health in Finland just looked at nursing students.

    They followed 174 nursing students from the start of their nursing program through the first five years of their nursing career. They found a high number of nurses with back pain right from the start (before going to school).

    The number of nursing students with back pain went up dramatically in the first year of school. About 30 percent of the nursing students reported back pain before starting school. At the end of nursing school this had jumped up to 72 percent. There was a slow but steady climb after that from 72 to 82 percent after five years as a nurse.

    Back pain before starting nursing school is a risk factor for back pain and disability later.

    Our local hospital wants to start a back school for people with back pain lasting more than one month. What can we use as measures of “success”?

    There are four measures used by many researchers when studying back pain. In fact these are considered the most important ones:

  • Pain (rated on a scale from zero for ‘no pain’ to 10 for ‘most pain’)
  • Number of days off work
  • Overall improvement (patient report)
  • Function

    Other measures can include motion, strength, and flexibility. These are considered secondary outcomes. There isn’t always a link between these measures and the clinical status of the patient.

    Sometimes medication use is also measured before, during, and after treatment.

  • My doctor wants me to go to a special program called “Back School.” What do they do at these schools?

    The very first “back school” was started in Sweden in 1969. The goal was to reduce pain and keep back pain from coming back.

    Today there are many different back schools around the United States and even the world. Each group may be slightly different. Most include information on lifting, posture, and work efficiency. Back exercises and core training are usually a part of the program.

    There are usually groups of patients who go through the back school together. A physical therapist supervises the activities and exercises. Groups meet once a week for one or two hours for six to eight weeks.

    I had a disc removed from my lower back. It was supposed to be a simple surgery but I ended up with a dural tear. How often does this happen?

    The covering around the spinal cord (and brain) is called the dural sac. Dural tears during spinal surgery are fairly common. Studies report a range from one to 17 percent. A recent study in Germany of over 1,200 patients placed this figure at around three percent.

    Most dural tears are repaired at the time of the original surgery. They are either stitched together or patched. Sometimes the tear isn’t visible and is diagnosed later on the basis of patient symptoms.

    My husband just came out of spinal surgery. They took two discs out and fused his spine. This is his third back surgery. This time he had a dural tear during the operation. The surgeon said it’s all been repaired so he’s okay. He didn’t have this problem with the first two surgeries…why now?

    The covering around the spinal cord is called the dural sac. Dural tears are more common when there is scar tissue from a previous surgery.

    The risk of dural tears also goes up when the surgery is complex or requires going back in to the same place surgery was done before.

    Your husband may have some symptoms from the dural tear. Headaches, dizziness, and nausea are the first signs. Back and leg pain are also common with this problem.

    The patient may have some continued symptoms and problems from the dural tear long after healing takes place. Researchers aren’t sure why this happens. It may be the way the tear is repaired. More studies are needed to help prevent long-term problems.

    I had a complex back surgery and ended up with headaches, back, and leg pain. The surgeon told me there’s a tear in the dural sac called a durotomy. I’ve been advised to have another operation to repair the problem. What will happen if I don’t do it?

    A recent study of long-term outcomes after durotomies has been reported. Patients were followed for up to 10 years. The results of their surgeries were compared to an equal number of patients who didn’t have a dural tear.

    The overall outcome was poor for those patients with the durotomy. They had all the same symptoms you’re reporting. They were limited in their daily activities. Some had to change jobs or even retire early because the pain kept them from doing functional activities.

    There’s no question from a medical point of view that the operation is required if there’s a leak of the cerebrospinal fluid. However you may or may not have relief of your symptoms.

    My wife is going to have a disc replacement in just a few weeks. She’s wondering how soon she’ll see results of this surgery.

    According to a recent study at Yale University, most patients report significant improvement by three months. They had less pain and more function. Some also reported decrease use of pain relievers as a positive result in the first three months.

    Problems can occur after any surgery and disc replacement is no exception. Bone fracture, infection, or subsidence can occur. Subsidence is the sinking down of the implant into the bone.

    If all goes well patients are completely satisfied with the results. Disc replacement instead of spinal fusion gives the patient motion and function. It also preserves the motion and function at the levels above and below the level of the implant.