Children often play the game rock-paper-scissors to see who goes first. Scissors always win over paper. Paper wins over rock. Rock wins over scissors. When it comes to chronic back pain, patients often feel like they are playing the same game. Drugs? Acupuncture? Manipulation? But in this case, there are no clear answers.
These researchers in Australia compared drugs, acupuncture, and manipulation in this clinical trial. They found that spinal manipulation was most successful for short-term relief of chronic pain, followed by acupuncture and then medication.
The authors reviewed results from other studies and point out the following:
In this study, pain intensity and frequency were measured at two, five, and nine weeks after the first session for each form of treatment. Spine range of motion was also measured.
Rock, paper, scissors? Drugs, acupuncture, manipulation? The authors conclude that spinal manipulation gives the best overall results. However, patients must be cleared for manipulation and free of any factors that could cause problems.